A toaster oven does something your microwave cannot: it actually cooks. It crisps instead of steams, browns instead of reheats, and handles toast, frozen snacks, small-batch baking, and reheated leftovers without firing up a full-size oven. The good news is you do not need to spend much to get one that does all of that well. This guide to the best toaster ovens under seventy-five dollars in 2026 is written mostly in a research voice, with one firsthand note about the oven I personally lean on for the same jobs.
Disclosure: SmartLifeItems is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
Quick Verdict: Budget Toaster Ovens Worth Buying
For most people, the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach is the budget standout, with a roll-top door that makes it genuinely easy to clean. If you want air-frying built in, the Black+Decker Crisp N Bake adds that for very little more, while the extra-wide Black+Decker is the one to get for bigger batches. The Oster covers the cheapest compact need, the COMFEE brings retro style, and the Hamilton Beach 31156 is the toasting specialist. Every pick below comes in under seventy-five dollars.
| Toaster Oven | Capacity | Functions | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hamilton Beach Easy Reach | 4 slices | Bake, broil, toast | Overall budget pick |
| Black+Decker Crisp N Bake | 4 slices | Air fry, bake, broil, toast, warm | Built-in air frying |
| Oster 4-Slice | 4 slices | Bake, broil, toast | Cheapest compact |
| COMFEE Retro | 4 slices | Bake, broil, toast | Retro style |
| Black+Decker Extra Wide | 8 slices | Convection, bake, broil, toast | Large batches |
| Hamilton Beach 31156 | 6 slices | Bake, broil, toast | Best toasting |
1. Hamilton Beach Easy Reach: Best Overall
The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach is the budget toaster oven that gets the basics right and adds one genuinely smart touch: a roll-top door that lifts up and out of the way instead of dropping down. That makes it easy to slide food in and out and to wipe crumbs without reaching over a hot door. In independent testing it produced evenly golden toast with a satisfying crunch, which is the core job most people buy a toaster oven for. It bakes, broils, and toasts, fits a small pizza, and costs very little.
Who it suits: most households wanting a simple, easy-to-clean toaster oven on a budget. If you are weighing this against a pop-up toaster, our explainer on toaster versus toaster oven helps.
2. Black+Decker Crisp N Bake Air Fry: Best with Air Frying
If you want air-frying without buying a separate machine, the Black+Decker Crisp N Bake is the budget way in. It is a five-in-one that bakes, broils, toasts, keeps warm, and air fries, crisping fries and frozen snacks with little or no oil, and it fits a nine-inch pizza. Reviewers like its simple manual dials and easy cleanup. The oven cavity runs a little short, so very tall dishes can be a squeeze, but for the price the added air-fry function is hard to argue with.
Who it suits: anyone who wants toaster-oven basics plus air frying in one cheap unit. To compare dedicated machines, see our roundup of air fryers and our guide to air fryer versus toaster oven.
3. Oster 4-Slice: Best Cheap Compact
The Oster four-slice is the answer when you want the lowest price and the smallest footprint. It covers the essentials, bake, broil, and toast, with simple controls and a compact body that fits where a bigger oven will not. It is not the unit for batch cooking or large dishes, but as a no-frills second oven for toast, reheating, and small jobs, it does what it promises without costing much.
Who it suits: tight counters, dorms, and anyone who wants the cheapest functional toaster oven. For other small-kitchen wins, see our guide to organizing a small kitchen.
4. COMFEE Retro: Best Style
The COMFEE Retro proves a budget toaster oven does not have to look like one. Its rounded retro design comes in colors that actually suit a kitchen counter, and underneath the looks it bakes, broils, and toasts with straightforward temperature and timer knobs. It fits four slices or a small pizza and even offers two rack positions. For anyone who cares how the appliance looks sitting out, it delivers character without a premium price.
Who it suits: style-conscious buyers who still want a bargain. It pairs well with the rest of a coordinated counter, like our picks for toasters.
5. Black+Decker Extra Wide Convection: Best for Large Batches
When you need to cook for more than one or two, the Black+Decker extra-wide convection is the budget pick that scales up. It is roomy enough to hold a large sheet pan or a twelve-inch pizza, and the convection fan helps it bake more evenly than basic ovens, which bakers in particular appreciate. It comes with a bake pan, broil rack, and toasting rack, and the simple dial controls keep it approachable. For family-size jobs under budget, it is the most capable option here.
Who it suits: families and anyone who bakes or cooks larger dishes. If you want even more capacity and functions, our guide to air fryer toaster oven combos covers the step up.
6. Hamilton Beach 31156: Best for Toasting
If your main use really is toast, the Hamilton Beach 31156 is the one to beat in this price range. It is a top-rated budget model that earns high marks for toasting time, color range, and turning out a full, even batch, with a wide temperature range and simple dial and lever controls. It also bakes and broils, fitting six slices or a small pizza. For households that want reliable, even toast first and everything else second, it is a smart, inexpensive choice.
Who it suits: toast lovers and value shoppers who want proven toasting performance. For more budget kitchen gear, see our toaster ovens under one hundred dollars roundup.
What I Use as My Toaster Oven
Here is my own firsthand piece. I do not keep a separate small toaster oven on the counter, because the large French-door oven I already own handles all of those jobs. It is an Emeril Lagasse French Door unit, and alongside air frying, it toasts, bakes, broils, and runs pizza and reheat settings, which are exactly the things a toaster oven is for. Over years of use it has done a consistently good job across those functions and stayed easy to clean, so it quietly replaced the need for a dedicated toaster oven in my kitchen.
I am including that as honest context, not as a budget recommendation, because a large French-door oven like mine costs well above seventy-five dollars and is a different class of appliance. If you have the counter space and want one machine to cover toasting, baking, and air frying together, the oven-style route is worth knowing about, and you can read more in our air fryers guide. But if you specifically want an affordable, compact toaster oven, the six picks above are the ones to shop, and none of them is the unit I personally use.
What to Look For in a Toaster Oven Under
Capacity
Match the size to your cooking. A four-slice oven suits one or two people and basic toast and reheating, while a six or eight-slice model handles a small pizza, a sheet pan, or batch baking. Bigger ovens take more counter space, so balance capacity against your kitchen.
Functions
Every toaster oven toasts, bakes, and broils, but extras vary. Convection improves baking evenness, and a built-in air-fry mode adds crisping without a second machine. Decide which of those you will actually use before paying for them.
Ease of cleaning
A removable crumb tray and a door that gets out of the way make a real difference in whether the oven stays clean. Roll-top and easy-access designs are easier to wipe out than standard drop-down doors that you have to reach over.
Controls and footprint
Simple dial controls are durable and easy, while digital presets add convenience at a slightly higher price. Measure your counter space too, since toaster ovens vary a lot in footprint and the largest budget models can be surprisingly big. For the rest of a budget countertop, see our picks for electric griddles, indoor grills, and food processors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best toaster oven under $75?
The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach is the best all-around budget pick thanks to its even toasting and easy-clean roll-top door, while the Black+Decker Crisp N Bake adds air frying for a little more. The right one depends on capacity and which extra functions you want.
Can a toaster oven replace a regular oven?
For small jobs, largely yes. Toaster ovens bake, broil, and reheat, and they use less energy and preheat faster than a full oven. They cannot match a full oven’s capacity, so big roasts and large batches still belong in the main oven.
Do I need a toaster oven with air fry?
Only if you want crisping without a separate machine. An air-fry mode is handy for fries and frozen snacks, but if you already own an air fryer or rarely make those foods, a simpler bake-broil-toast model saves money.
What size toaster oven should I buy?
A four-slice model suits one or two people and basic tasks, while six and eight-slice ovens fit a small pizza, a sheet pan, or family batches. Choose the smallest size that comfortably fits what you cook to save counter space.
Are cheap toaster ovens any good?
Yes. Several budget models toast and bake as well as pricier ones, since the basics are well established. You mainly pay more for convection, air fry, digital presets, and larger capacity, not necessarily for better toast.
Convection or regular toaster oven?
Convection circulates hot air for more even, slightly faster cooking, which bakers especially value. If you bake often or cook multiple racks, convection is worth it; for plain toasting and reheating, a regular model is fine.
How do I clean a toaster oven?
Unplug and cool it, then remove and wash the crumb tray and racks, and wipe the interior with a damp cloth. Doing this regularly prevents buildup that can smoke or smell, and an easy-access door makes the job much quicker.
Is a toaster oven or air fryer better?
They overlap but differ. A toaster oven is more versatile and holds larger dishes, while a dedicated air fryer crisps small batches faster. Many people choose a toaster oven with an air-fry mode to get both in one machine.
Related Reading
Explore more: dutch ovens under 50, hand mixers under 50, difference between convection and conventional ovens, under sink organizers, pizza stones for home ovens, microwave ovens, rice cookers under 50, and immersion blenders under 50. Also explore: egg cookers.
Recommended Reading
See also our guides to dutch ovens, and difference between convection and conventional ovens.
